TESTRUGBY.com TESTRUGBY.com
Opinionated Rugby Commentary - by Fans for Fans
Spill what you really think about events in the rugby world.
 
My Rugby Rants Add a New Rugby Rant
06 Aug 2018 by herbsconcrete 64 views 2 Comments
Hire Experts For Concrete Cutting Making The Best
Concrete Driveways Adelaide is often recommended because of their low servicing. While road needs maintenance over several decades, concrete, once set up and enclosed, needs very little care. However, the concrete costs more than the road to set up, so you do pay a price for the time you will save.
23 Jul 2018 by lease cleaning 29 views 0 Comments
Cleaning a House? The Daunting Task Now Made Easy
Being heavy surpassed with the showering powder also can shorten the life of your washing device as it creates extra suds.
20 Jul 2018 by lease cleaning 31 views 0 Comments
Take A Deep Breath And Clean Your House!
Continually don’t forget to change the cloths at the same time as you’re cleansing Carpet Cleaning Adelaide.
26 Mar 2018 by blackhorsefilm 35 views 0 Comments
Video Making for Business
Black Horse Film is a leading music video production company offers a range of photography, videography and corporate video production services throughout the Denver, Colorado and surrounding area.
23 Sep 2017 by hansensteven 24 views 0 Comments
Betway Casino Review
Betway Casino Review
18 Aug 2016 by The Commish 30 views 1 Comments
National Squads based on 2016 Super Rugby
Check out who all the performers were by country, based on the full 2016 Super Rugby Series.
18 Aug 2016 by The Commish 24 views 0 Comments
Best Performers Overall - Super Rugby 2016
Check out the best Fantasy players and best fifteen squad of all countries for the entire Super Rugby 2016 Season.
17 Jul 2016 by The Commish 32 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 17 - Best Starting 15
It's the end of the Reound Robin play - check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
17 Jul 2016 by The Commish 31 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 17 - Best Possible Fantasy Team
It's the end of the round robin - check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
04 Jul 2016 by The Commish 22 views 0 Comments
Best Squads by Country
Take a look at who the performers are within each country.
03 Jul 2016 by The Commish 35 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 15 - Best Starting 15
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
03 Jul 2016 by The Commish 27 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 15 - Best Possible Fantasy Team
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
08 Apr 2016 by The Commish 35 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 6 - Best Starting 15
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
08 Apr 2016 by The Commish 24 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 6 - Best Possible Fantasy Team
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
29 Mar 2016 by The Commish 34 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 5 - Best Starting 15
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
29 Mar 2016 by The Commish 24 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 5 - Best Possible Fantasy Team
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
20 Mar 2016 by The Commish 21 views 0 Comments
Super 15 Round 4 - Best Starting 15
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
20 Mar 2016 by The Commish 27 views 0 Comments
Super Rugby - Best Fantasy Players
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say.
20 Mar 2016 by The Commish 28 views 0 Comments
6 Nations Full Series - Best Starting 15
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say for the final Round and the entire Series.
20 Mar 2016 by The Commish 29 views 0 Comments
6 Nations Full Series - Best Fantasy Players
Check out the individual performers - here is what the stats say for the full series.
Next
Prev
Quota System Returns to SA Rugby - Still Relevant? 7 views 2 Comments
15 August 2013 by The Swede Eaters
 

South Africa will reintroduce a quota system for the Vodacom Cup, do you think there is still room for racism in sport?

South African Rugby boss Oregan Hoskins announced that teams in the Vodacom Cup will be required to field seven coloured players in their 22 man squads and five in their starting fifteen starting in 2014.  This quota system is hoped to increase the number of coloured players making it into the Currie Cup and Super Rugby.  It is interesting in this day and age that players are still picked on their skin colour rather than merit necessarily.  This could potentially cost white players a spot in the Vodacom Cup competition, but these players will probably find contracts overseas.

Is there room for racism in rugby still in 2013? 

While I can see where the bosses are coming from by wanting to help young coloured and black players get into top level rugby, I wonder if this is the best way to do it?  Most other countries are so used to players being selected on merit, so it is a funny idea for most to the fathom.

For the record, the Vodacom Cup runs at the same time as Super Rugby and works as a developmental competition.  I wonder if New Zealand has enough depth for a similar competition to run at the same time as Super Rugby?  I also doubt New Zealand has the depth to allow a certain number of coloured players into each team. 


There were days when the South African Super Rugby teams had a quota system, but there were times when some players included were out of their depth at that level of rugby and it can become dangerous especially in front row positions. 

Should South African rugby go back to a quota system for coloured and black players?  Do you agree with this decision?

http://www.superrugbytips.com/2013/08/sa-rugby-to-re-introduce-quota-system.html



Previous Story
Next Story
Tags: SA Rugby, Super Rugby,



comment Comments (2)
Rating:
Site User Upload

2 . Sharkie cavin 17 Aug 2013 05:32 AM
Goooood idea...how about the same in the soccer teams???????????develop some white players in that sport as well.....same shit...different sport.....

Site User Upload

1 . DeBlocq 16 Aug 2013 05:06 AM
This is all the result of a popular post-1994 buzzword: "transformation". This means giving people who were previously-disadvantaged a chance to kickstart their careers, be it in industry, business or sport.

South African rugby is still very much dominated by white players. However, black people in South Africa (in general terms) prefer soccer. I think this accounts for the lack of black players coming through the developmental programs, and teams are going to have to look very hard to fill the quotas that have been imposed (7 in each starting 22, 5 in the starting 15 and at least 2 forwards - most black players are speedy outside backs).

Despite the moral idea of promoting less capable black players ahead of white, the logistical issue is also a problem. Unless they can prove that racism is playing in a role in stunting black players' careers, I don't think this is feasible.

It's not a problem that we have a "black" sport and a "white" sport, and I think crossover is generally encouraged. We have had some great black players who managed just fine in this system (Habana, Pietersen, Mtawarira, Kolisi, Basson to name a few in the current Bok scope, as well as historical names like Breyten Paulse, Ashwin Willemse, Chavanga and Chester Williams).

Page 1
Not registered yet? Register Now to be able to post comments.
Already registered? Login Here
none
Registered Users
Email (or Alias):

Password:

Login
? Forgot password
none

Register Here


NEW
Squad Shares
How to Play



TESTRUGBY.com © FitSurfer Fantasy Games Limited. Private information collected for this website is governed by our Privacy Policy
Powered by streamSWEET CMS